March 8, 2026

Nino’s

This place has history. What started in the upper east side back in 1985 has now become the backbone of upper east siders Italian fix.

Why This Restaurant Exists

A last minute valentines day reservation that turned into one of those rare meals you continue replaying in your head after it ends it did not disappoint. The three course prix fixe offered curated tastes of Nino’s most beloved dishes the kind of menu that makes you feel like you are getting the absolute best of everything in one meal.

The Experience

What stood out immediately was the warmth. Selimaj the owner came around to each table greeting everyone that felt so genuine and unforced. It set the tone for the night as welcoming and hospitable. Even though the rush of valentines day, the pacing of the food was well done. The food arrived smoothly, keeping the evening flowing.

The Food

The penne vodka is without gestation one of the best in NYC and that is not said lightly. The pasta is cooked to a perfect al dente coated in a sauce that rich and creamy yet not feeling heavy.

The branzino was delicate and clean while the short ribs were deeply flavorful and fell off the bone effortlessly. To finish, we had a hearty tiramisu that felt comforting and transportive that brings you back to an italian kitchen.

Each dish felt intentional. Luxuriously simple, yet executed with the kind fo precious that makes it unforgettable.

The Space & Neighborhood

Tucked into turtle bay, Nino’s feels like a quiet escape from usual Manhattan pace. The space is polished but not overly formal, with a live piano adding just the right touch of classic charm. It is the kind of place that feels equally suited for a date night or intimate dinner.

One Observation

There is clear emphasis on consistency not just in food but entire experience. From service to execution, everything feels intentional and well practiced.

Final Take

Nino’s delivers from the moment you walk in to the final bite. The depth of flavor, the warmth in service and effortless atmosphere make it a place you will want to return to whether for a special occasion or simply a great night out.